Sunday, March 6, 2016

Unlikeable Messages in Social Media

Technology doesn't "make" us less civil, but without intervention, does some software accentuate our worst tendencies?  And can we design software to make civility the default?

"Play Nice! How the Internet is Trying to Design Out Toxic Behavior" describes a range of efforts underway to make Twitter and Facebook less subject to abusive comments and extremist propaganda, as well as efforts to design alternative platforms.  One of the alternatives is Civil Comments. As The Guardian's Gaby Hinsloff explains:

"The idea is simple (although the software is so complex it took a year to build): before posting a comment in a forum or below an article, users must rate two randomly selected comments from others for quality of argument and civility (defined as an absence of personal attacks or abuse). Ratings are crunched to build up a picture of what users of any given site will tolerate, which is then useful for flagging potentially offensive material." 

The system tries to simulate the "slight sense of social inhibition" that we might feel when speaking to a flesh-and-blood person. Early pilot testing suggests that people can still joke and snark but the ad hominem attacks and abuse are gone. This and other attempts to design civil software is harnessing the majority of reasonable users to regulate the small minority of abusive trolls.



While some developers are working on making the internet a nicer place, Facebook has given us the ability to show an expanded range of negative emotions that go beyond "like."  "Reactions: Not Everything in Life is Likable" describes how Facebook developed it's new reactions.  The process is more challenging than you might expect, particularly when you consider that Facebook is a global platform.  Users from many different languages and cultures are accessing the same handful of icons and, potentially, interacting with one another.


 As Geoff Teehan explains, "The whole point of expanding reactions is to have a universally understood vocabulary with which anyone can better and more richly express themselves." 

 As reactions to someone else's post, these symbols seemed design to communicate shared sadness, outrage, or surprise, rather than to say "I'm mad AT you."  It will be interesting to see how norms for usage and interpretation  evolve.